Doesn’t it seem every year that the Patriots always have an extra advantage against the Bills? Well, it seems that they have…
I’m going to keep this very brief as I found an article that sums my feelings on Walsh’s tapes up fairly well, written by Pat Duffy at Buffalowdown.com, click here for that link.
Also check out Chris Brown’s blog on BuffaloBills.com for more insight by clicking here.
Here are my general thoughts on this year’s first round selections with my grade:
1. Miami: Jake Long OT Michigan – Unfortunately, Bill Parcells knows what he’s doing in Miami. The Dolphins have had one of the porous offensive lines in the league over the last few years, and by taking Long they take a giant leap towards fixing this problem. This pick will be crucial for the development of John Beck and/or Chad Henne. Grade: A-
2. St. Louis: Chris Long DE Virginia – Arguably the best defensive line prospect in the draft, Long will add and instinct punch to the Rams pass rush and allow them to keep Adam Carriker at defensive tackle. Dorsey was a possibility here as well but would then force St. Louis to move Carriker outside. Grade: A-
3. Atlanta: Matt Ryan QB Boston College – This pick signals the end of the Michael Vick era in Atlanta. With Chris Redman playing reasonably well at the end of last season and with needs on the defensive line, Dorsey would make just as much sense as well. However, I cannot fault the Falcons for wanting to start a new era and fix its image. Grade: A-
4. Oakland: Darren McFadden RB Arkansas – May be the single best prospect in the draft but slips with Miami having Ronnie Brown, St. Louis having Stephen Jackson and Atlanta acquiring Michael Turner over the off-season. Al Davis obviously sees McFadden having a similar impact as Adrian Peterson did in Minnesota, thus taking him even though Justin Fargas proved to be a productive back and still having LaMont Jordan on the roster. Defensive end was another pressing need and Gholston could have just as easily gone here after last year’s disappointing pass rush and seeing how there already is a logjam in the backfield. Grade: B
5. Kansas City: Glenn Dorsey DT LSU – The Chiefs never really recovered from the Ryan Sims pick made several years ago so Dorsey will be looked upon to immediately remedy that area. Gholston could have went here also as they traded away the AFC’s sack leader to Minnesota. Grade: B
6. NY Jets: Vernon Gholston DE Ohio State – You would have to assume that they wanted McFadden to drop here, but the Jets still get one of the top players on the board and fill a need. Gholston will either need to be moved to outside linebacker in the 3-4 scheme or bulk up and play defensive end. Grade: B+
7. New Orleans: Sedrick Ellis DT USC – Nice move in trading up to get the man they wanted, as it looked like Cincinnati was eyeing him a pick before them. Ellis is probably the next best defender on the board at this point and a good selection for them as they could use help nearly anywhere on the defensive side of the ball. Grade: A-
8. Jacksonville: Derrick Harvey DE Florida - Vaulted up to take him, the Jaguars feared with New England moving back they were looking to take Harvey and with Ryan going to Atlanta, Baltimore looked to drop down in the first round. I don’t feel this is as big of a reach as people think. Jacksonville realizes that if it wants to leap frog Indianapolis and beat New England that they will need to apply more pressure to quarterbacks like Manning and Brady and thus hope Harvey and be effective in this role. Grade: B
9. Cincinnati: Keith Rivers OLB USC - No wide receivers are worthy of being taken at this point, so the Bengals turn to the other side of the ball. Rivers will move into a similar role that David Pollack had played before his career-ending injury. Grade: B+
10. New England: Jerod Mayo ILB Tennessee - In the past, the rule is that Belichick rather collect veteran linebackers rather than drafting one high. Of course, this turns out to year he breaks the trend and takes Mayo. Don’t get me wrong, the Patriots definitely need a player like Mayo to infuse some more speed and youth to the linebacker core but his selection does break a common trend. Mayo is versatile, able to play inside or outside, and has very good speed. However, I think that New England could have moved further down in the round to pick him and also could have used this pick to take whomever they felt was the best cornerback in the draft with the losses of both Asante Samuel and Randall Gay. Grade: B+
11. Buffalo: Leodis McKelvin CB Troy - See my previous post for my thoughts. Grade: A-
12. Denver: Ryan Clady OT Boise State – Nice pick here to fill a need with the surprise retirement of Matt Lepsis, could have also went with Branden Albert, Chris Williams or Jeff Otah so the Broncos pick the guy who best fits into their blocking scheme. Grade: B+
13. Carolina: Jonathan Stewart RB Oregon – I thought Rashard Mendenhall would have been a better fit for their offense but Stewart is probably the better all around player. Offensive line was another pressing need that could have been addressed here or even quarterback with Jake Delhomme’s health in question. Grade: B
14. Chicago: Chris Williams OT Vanderbilt – Mendenhall, quarterback or even receiver could have gone here also but offensive line was a thorn in the Bears side last year, too. Grade: B
15. Kansas City: Branden Albert G Virginia – Great value pick here as Albert was consider a legitimate top 10 pick and was a strong possibility at the five spot. Albert is probably the best guard prospect since Steve Hutchinson and has the ability to make the move over to offensive tackle in the pros. No defensive ends of good value at this point. Grade: A
16. Arizona: Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie CB Tennessee State – Cornerback comes a glaring need for the Cardinals again as they move Antrell Rolle to safety. Mendenhall was a strong possibility here has he seemed to fit Ken Whisenhunt’s rushing attack better than Edgerrin James has. Grade: B+
17. Detroit: Gosder Cherilus OT Boston College – The team could use some offensive line help, but do they feel that Tatum Bell is the answer at running back with Mendenhall still on the board? This is a clear cut reach here too as he’s projected to play right tackle in the NFL and was not this highly rated overall. Detroit could have really benefited from trading down from this spot and picking up some value. Heck, at least they didn’t take another wide receiver. Grade: B-
18. Baltimore: Joe Flacco QB Delaware – First the Ravens trade back, then they trade up for a guy that would have probably still been there that late in the round, second consecutive reach. I don’t understand why they would have moved this far up to take him. Did they feel Gruden was a threat to add to the quarterback menagerie in Tampa Bay? The more I look at this pick, the more I see Kyle Boller written all over it. Physically gifted but will need to prove he can handle the speed of the game coming from a small school. It seems Ozzie Newsome does a great job drafting for Baltimore, besides at the quarterback position. On top of it, the team could have taken a corner at this point such as Mike Jenkins or Aqib Talib. Grade: C+
19. Carolina: Jeff Otah OT Pittsburgh – The Panthers make a good trade up to take Otah who is of very good value, a little surprised the Eagles didn’t stay steady here and take him with their aging bookend tackles. Grade: A-
20. Tampa Bay: Aqib Talib CB Kansas – I think wide receiver like Devin Thomas would have made more sense here with the ageless wonders of Joey Galloway and Ike Hilliard being the returning starters, Michael Clayton sinking lower on the depth chart and no other wide outs really making any other significant impact on their roster. Regardless, Talib should be a decent fit in the Tampa Cover 2 scheme. Grade: B-
21. Atlanta: Sam Baker OT USC – The Falcons had three prospects in mind with the No. 3 pick, Dorsey, Jake Long and Ryan. With the quarterback need being taken care of, Atlanta felt the need to further protect their young signal caller’s blindside, this moving back into the first round to take Baker. I’m assuming that the trade comes on fear that Pittsburgh had an eye on Baker. The USC product will be a very effective pass blocker for them but need to work on his run blocking, which hurt his draft stock which was at one time in the top 10. Grade: B
22. Dallas: Felix Jones RB Arkansas - The worst kept secret in the draft was that Jerry Jones wanted to draft a tailback from his alma mater. Jones is the quick, speedy back that will be a very good complement to Marion Barber, thus getting the selection over Mendenhall. Cornerback and wide receiver could have also gone here. Grade: B+
23. Pittsburgh: Rashad Mendenhall RB Illinois - The workhorse back that the Steel City loves and comes after both Willie Parker and Najeh Davenport went down late in the season with serious injuries. You can never have too many hard nosed running backs in this type of offense. Wide receiver could have gone here too with Big Ben’s request for a taller target and offensive line, too but Cherilus was already taken. Grade: B+
24. Tennessee: Chris Johnson RB East Carolina – This is the biggest reach in the first round, bar none. Yes, Johnson has amazing speed but did the Titans forget they also have LenDale White and Chris Henry on their roster (who they spend two high draft picks on already)? The problem with their offense last year was the wide receivers Vince Young had to work with so I don’t see this helping out their problems tremendously unless they have plans of converting him to wide out. Grade: D+
25. Dallas: Mike Jenkins CB South Florida – Great value here for the last of the four potential shutdown corners in this year’s draft. The Cowboys also had their shot at whomever they felt was the best wide out in the draft here. Grade: A-
26. Houston: Duane Brown OT Virginia Tech – Well, the Texans finally took their franchise left tackle they’ve been looking for during their entire existence, although it was still a bit of a reach. If they would have stayed put, they could have taken Otah or even Sam Baker at their spot, both superior prospects. Grade: B
27. San Diego: Antoine Cason CB Arizona – The Chargers could use a bit of help in the secondary and turn one state over to find it. Cason may not have all the physical tools you would want, but he is a weathered veteran of the air battles that occur in the Pac-10 year in and year out. Grade: A-
28. Seattle: Lawrence Jackson DE USC – Another reach here as Philip Merling or even Calais Campbell would have been better fits. Could have possibly gone tight end here with Dustin Keller or may have taken a running back that would have slipped. Ultimately, the Seahawks probably should have traded down to get better value. Grade: C+
29. San Francisco: Kentwan Balmer DT North Carolina – This is just about right in terms of value for Balmer at this spot, who will be replacing Bryant Young. Yet, beware the last high profile UNC d-tackle (Sims). Wide receiver could have also gone here. Grade: B+
30. NY Jets: Dustin Keller TE Purdue – Not sure if there was that big of a need to trade up for Keller but it was done. Keller should be able to add another dimension to the Jets passing attack whether it is Pennington or Clemens and is an upgrade over Chris Baker. His blocking leaves something to be yearned though. Grade: B+
31. NY Giants: Kenny Phillips S Miami (FL) – Will take over for Gibril Wilson who left in free agency and is a fairly good value at this point. Grade: A-